Stocks continue surging to record highs. Here's how to hedge

CNBC | May 22, 2026 at 06:04 PM UTC
Bullish 78% Confidence Majority Agreement
Read Original Article

Key Points

  • One-month, 30-delta put options now cost significantly less than during March volatility, with SPY June 26th $730 puts priced at approximately $7.40 or 1% of current levels
  • Market breadth concerns emerge as the Russell 2000 has stalled near prior highs while cap-weighted indexes push higher, suggesting divergence in rally participation
  • Fundamental risks remain unresolved including Fed sidelined by higher oil-driven inflation, elevated Treasury yields, and persistent safe-haven demand in gold despite recent retreat

AI Summary

Summary: Stocks Surge to Record Highs – Hedging Strategies Recommended

Market Performance:

The market has rallied over 17% from March lows, driven by tariff relief optimism, resilient corporate earnings, and a semiconductor sector rebound. Despite reaching new records, analysts suggest this creates an opportune moment for portfolio protection.

Key Investment Thesis:

With volatility compressed and the VIX in the high teens—well below March stress levels—hedging costs have decreased significantly. One-month, 2-2.5% out-of-the-money put options (30-delta) now cost considerably less than during the March selloff, making protection more affordable.

Specific Hedging Strategy:

Investors can purchase 30-day, 30-delta puts for approximately $7.40 (roughly 1% of SPY's current level). Example: June 26th weekly $730 strike puts on SPY provide downside protection at current implied volatility levels.

Market Concerns:

  • Fundamental risks remain: Rally drivers (tariff progress, earnings resilience) represent momentum rather than resolved fundamentals
  • Fed constraint: Higher oil prices pushing inflation upward, keeping the Federal Reserve sidelined
  • Elevated Treasury yields: Remain high relative to year-to-date lows
  • Gold prices: Continue signaling institutional safe-haven demand persists
  • Breadth divergence: Market breadth has stalled near prior highs while cap-weighted indices advance

Strategic Rationale:

After a 17% gain, portfolios with unrealized profits face asymmetric risk—downside exposure has increased while marginal upside benefits diminish. The article emphasizes buying protection when affordable ("after the smoke clears") rather than during crisis periods. Investors should actively manage hedges by rolling positions if puts move in-the-money to maximize protection value.

Model Analysis Breakdown

Model Sentiment Confidence
GPT-5-mini Bullish 75%
Claude 4.5 Haiku Bullish 70%
Gemini 2.5 Flash Neutral 90%
Consensus Bullish 78%