Sentiment Shift Shows Extreme Optimism in Options Buyers

Schaeffers Research | May 11, 2026 at 12:31 PM UTC
Bullish 75% Confidence Unanimous Agreement
Read Original Article

Key Points

  • The SPX has risen 5% in three weeks despite entering 'overbought' territory on its 14-day RSI, demonstrating strong momentum that has rendered traditional oversold indicators ineffective.
  • Institutional investors are hedging through SPY put options and VIX call buying, with the VIX 20-day call/put ratio exceeding 4.0 for the first time since January, historically preceding market weakness.
  • While extreme optimism among short-term traders is evident, analysts recommend staying bullish until the SPX closes below its 10-day moving average (projected around 7,360), signaling a potential momentum shift.

AI Summary

Summary

Market Overview:

The S&P 500 Index (SPX) continues demonstrating strong upward momentum, closing at 7,398.93—up 2% above its 10-day moving average and marking its sixth consecutive weekly gain. The index has rallied 155 points from late March and gained 5% in the three weeks since entering "overbought" territory on its 14-day RSI. The SPX reached another all-time high with no closes below the 10-day moving average since April 1, 2026.

Key Technical Indicators:

  • SPX's 10-day moving average rising at approximately 23 points daily, projected to reach 7,360 by week's end
  • 14-day RSI in overbought territory for nearly one month
  • Potential resistance zone identified at 7,500-7,530 (representing 10% above 2025's close)

Sentiment Analysis:

Options traders have shifted from extreme pessimism at March's bottom to extreme optimism. Warning signs include institutional hedging through SPY put options and increased VIX call buying, with the 20-day buy-to-open call/put ratio exceeding 4.0 for the first time since January—historically preceding SPX weakness.

Market Implications:

Senior analyst Todd Salamone advises maintaining bullish positions while monitoring momentum indicators. A close below the 10-day moving average wouldn't necessarily trigger a sell signal given the strength of the uptrend. However, extreme optimism combined with rising VIX call activity suggests potential volatility ahead. Investors anchored to year-to-date gains may consider slight risk reduction near the 7,500-7,530 level.

Geopolitical developments, including potential Iran peace deal negotiations, continue influencing market sentiment and hedging activity.

Model Analysis Breakdown

Model Sentiment Confidence
GPT-5-mini Bullish 72%
Claude 4.5 Haiku Bullish 70%
Gemini 2.5 Flash Bullish 85%
Consensus Bullish 75%